Category Archives: Season 3

Listen to the story of Susan Newell who was the last woman in Scotland to face capital punishment. Was she pushed into murdering a young boy or was she inherently wicked?

Who would want to murder a pair of beloved professors from Dartmouth College? Investigators were stumped as to who and what their motive may have been. Listen to the story of the Ivy League Murders and how the least likely pair of suspects turned out to be the very killers investigators were looking for.

A beautiful mother of three goes missing. Her close family has no idea what happened to her. All they know is that her husband of twenty-plus years is no longer cooperating with the police. Listen to the story about the disappearance of May “Maya” Millete from Chula Vista, California in January 2020. helpfindmaya.com

On July 12, 2008, 34-year-old mother of two, Nancy Cooper supposedly went out for a jog never to be seen alive again. Who would want to kill this kind-hearted,  fun-loving mother who got along well with everyone except maybe the person that ended her life?

Who was Daniel Perez? The people close to him knew him as one of three angels that possessed special powers. Listen to the story of how one man conned his way to a lifestyle of leisure by convincing others that he alone had the power to bring them back to life.

On December 23, 1996, the body of 39-year-old Sophie Toscan du Plantier was discovered by her neighbor outside her holiday home in West Cork, Ireland. Who would commit such a heinous crime just days before Christmas? Listen to part one as we cover the early days of the investigation.

In 1870 the Bloody Benders obtained a 160-acre property along the Osage Trail and established a general supply store and inn for weary travelers. In 1871 bodies were discovered nearby and the disappearance of a prominent doctor soon lead his family and the surrounding community to suspect that all was not right at The Bender Inn.

In 2008, 38-year-old John Altinger emailed friends that he was taking off to Costa Rica with a woman he just met. They were shocked by this turn of events. Listen to the story of how good friends stopped Mark Twitchel. A budding serial killer who fancied himself after the TV character Dexter.

An abandoned car was found on a New Jersey bridge. Was it a missing person case, or something more? What happened to 19-year-old Sarah Stern? The answer sent shock waves through the close-knit community of Neptune. Listen to the story of how a young woman’s childhood friends committed the ultimate betrayal.

In August of 1969, the city of Memphis, Tennessee was living in fear due to a spree killer on the loose. For 29 days a killer terrorized the citizen of Memphis. Learn how George Howard Putt kept a city on edge never knowing where or when he would strike again.